We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. By browsing our website, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies.

 

Change preferences Change preferences

Tracking and performance cookies

Off
On
These cookies are used to collect information to analyze the traffic to our website and how visitors are using our website.For example, these cookies may track things such as how long you spend on the website or the pages you visit which helps us to understand how we can improve our website site for you.The information collected through these tracking and performance cookies do not identify any individual visitor.
More info
Skip to main content
Logo
  • Our services
    • Our services
    • Education Technology
      • Education Technology
      • Cyber Security
      • Digital Transformation
      • Digital Education and Strategy Services
      • Safeguarding
      • Support Services
    • Finance and Governance
      • Finance and Governance
      • Governor Services
      • Clerking Services
      • Finance Services
      • Financial Compliance
      • Finance Software
      • Information Governance
    • People Solutions
      • People Solutions
      • People Proposition Planning
      • HR Advice and Guidance
      • Payroll and HR Administration
      • Health, Safety & Wellbeing
    • Property and Facilities
      • Property and Facilities
      • Asset Management
      • Maintenance and Compliance
      • Sustainability, Design and Development
      • Catering Services
      • Cleaning Services
      • Grounds Maintenance
    • Pupil Skills and Development
      • Pupil Skills and Development
      • Outdoor Education
      • SEN & Inclusion
      • STEM
      • Music Service Staffordshire
      • School Improvement
      • Digital Education and Strategy Services
  • Case studies
  • News & insights
  • Work with us
aA
  • About
  • Contact

Insight

Holding your school leaders to account with effective challenge

Placeholder
Date Published

04/02/2021

Reading time

5 minutes

Here we look at some key areas for school governors to consider when challenging leaders.

Understanding how and when to hold leaders to account can be a really emotive subject, one that governors must approach sensitively and sensibly.

As governors, our job is to hold school leaders to account for our children’s educational performance and to make sure that they’re spending money effectively. But how can we do that without overstepping the mark and becoming too operational? If we ask too many questions, does that mean that we don’t trust them? If we ask for more evidence and want to visit school to do our own checks-and-balance exercise, what message does that send to them?

It’s our job to ask questions but, to be effective and to foster a good working relationship with members of staff, we need to do this respectfully. We’re the school’s strategic leaders but our headteacher is the operational leader, so we need to respect their position and the fact that they understand the day-to-day struggles of school life.

A great starting point when considering how to ask questions is the Seven Principles of Public Life. These are:

  • Selflessness
  • Integrity
  • Objectivity
  • Accountability
  • Openness
  • Honesty
  • Leadership.

It’s worth keeping these in mind when considering how we challenge our leaders and hold them to account (our tone of voice and body language are both indicators of our relationship with them). The relationship between governors and the headteacher is vital, even more so the relationship between the chair of governors and the headteacher.

Think about the subjects that you want to ask about. The three core functions of governance should influence all your challenging questions. There’s a thought process that says if governors are asking questions that couldn’t sit under one of the three core functions, they shouldn’t be asking them. And remember about being strategic, not operational: governance is a thinking role, not a doing role.

There are two types of questions that governors may be asking - questions for clarity and questions for evidence. We all need to ask questions for clarity, but these shouldn’t be recorded in minutes. The most important type of questions, though, is questions for evidence, or to find out more information. These questions are the basis of all effective challenge, and they need to be fully minuted as Ofsted will be looking for evidence that governors are effectively challenging school leaders. It wants to know if they are exploring forensically and asking probing questions or just accepting information at face value.

Governors need to consider their reasons for challenging their headteacher. Is it because:

  • They want more information?
  • They’re interested?
  • They don’t trust the information being given?

They also need to understand their motivation for challenging their headteacher. Some headteachers may resent being constantly challenged. They do accept that governors have to hold them to account but being constantly challenged and cross-examined on every single piece of information is extremely draining. To repeat, remember to be strategic and to not stray into the operational territory.

A final word: it’s governors’ right and duty to ask questions and to challenge effectively and respectfully. It demonstrates effective governance and governors in most situations act as the employers in law, so have every right to challenge and ask questions. It’s the manner in which the questions are asked that defines an open, transparent and trusting relationship between governors and headteachers.

Make an Enquiry

Contact us to enquire about our services
Send us a message
Or, call us on 0333 300 1900

Links

  • Contact
  • Careers

Social

Connect with us through our social channels

Legal

  • Privacy Notice
  • Cookies
  • Accessibility
  • Modern Slavery Act